Comparison of Methods for Removing Petroleum Products from Locomotive Depot Wastewater
Litsenziya: cc-by
Annotatsiya
Six methods of removing petroleum products from locomotive depot wastewater (gravity separation, coagulation-flocculation, flotation, adsorption, membrane filtration and biological treatment) were compared by treatment efficiency, cost, energy use, waste generation and operational complexity. Criteria weights were derived by AHP (consistency ratio CR = 0.007), and the methods were ranked by TOPSIS and the weighted sum model. The Termez locomotive depot test report was used as the baseline (petroleum products 0.7 mg/l, 70% of the limit). The ranking depends on the weights: membrane filtration leads when efficiency is prioritised, gravity separation when cost and simplicity are; adsorption ranks last in all scenarios. The method scores are expert judgements based on published data, not experimental measurements.
Hali tarjima qilinmagan